T24 vs. CFP this week
The committee’s latest ranking came out on Nov. 17. It covers games through week 11. Here it is next to the Yardstick’s ranking for the same week, so both are judging the same games.
Higher with the committee
- Boise State 9-1Committee #17 · Yardstick #25
- Arizona 7-3Committee #19 · Yardstick #27
- Houston 7-3Committee #20 · Yardstick #28
- Utah 10-0Committee #2 · Yardstick #6
| Team | Record then | Committee | Yardstick | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Georgia | 9-1 | #1 | #1 | same |
| Utah | 10-0 | #2 | #6 | 4 higher with the committee |
| Alabama | 8-2 | #3 | #5 | 2 higher with the committee |
| UCLA | 10-0 | #4 | #8 | 4 higher with the committee |
| Texas | 8-2 | #5 | #2 | 3 lower with the committee |
| Notre Dame | 9-1 | #6 | #3 | 3 lower with the committee |
| Miami | 9-1 | #7 | #7 | same |
| Indiana | 9-1 | #8 | #9 | 1 higher with the committee |
| Tennessee | 8-2 | #9 | #4 | 5 lower with the committee |
| BYU | 8-2 | #10 | #11 | 1 higher with the committee |
| Wake Forest | 9-1 | #11 | #10 | 1 lower with the committee |
| Texas Tech | 9-1 | #12 | #13 | 1 higher with the committee |
| Oregon | 7-3 | #13 | #14 | 1 higher with the committee |
| Ohio State | 7-3 | #14 | #16 | 2 higher with the committee |
| Iowa | 8-2 | #15 | #17 | 2 higher with the committee |
| Kentucky | 7-3 | #16 | #12 | 4 lower with the committee |
| Boise State | 9-1 | #17 | #25 | 8 higher with the committee |
| USC | 7-3 | #18 | #15 | 3 lower with the committee |
| Arizona | 7-3 | #19 | #27 | 8 higher with the committee |
| Houston | 7-3 | #20 | #28 | 8 higher with the committee |
| South Carolina | 6-4 | #21 | #18 | 3 lower with the committee |
| Oklahoma | 6-4 | #22 | #19 | 3 lower with the committee |
| Louisville | 7-3 | #23 | #26 | 3 higher with the committee |
| Florida | 6-4 | #24 | #23 | 1 lower with the committee |
| Ole Miss | 6-4 | #25 | #20 | 5 lower with the committee |
| LSU | 6-4 | – | #21 | 9 lower with the committee |
| Missouri | 6-4 | – | #22 | 8 lower with the committee |
| Auburn | 6-4 | – | #24 | 6 lower with the committee |
A team the committee left out counts as #30. The committee’s next ranking replaces this one when it comes out. This comparison is for reference: the Yardstick is not tuned to match the committee.
At season’s end: how far apart are they?
The Yardstick was run on the last five seasons, 2021 to 2025, and set beside the committee’s final top 25.
Where they differ, the gaps follow clear patterns:
Three or more losses, hard schedule
The committee ranks these teams about 2 spots lower
| Team | Committee | Yardstick |
|---|---|---|
| Texas A&M2024 · 8-4 | left out | #16 |
| Wisconsin2021 · 8-4 | left out | #20 |
| Mississippi State2022 · 8-4 | #22 | #13 |
These teams played a top-30 schedule. The committee counts losses first.
Three or more losses, easier schedule
The committee ranks these teams about 2 spots higher
| Team | Committee | Yardstick |
|---|---|---|
| NC State2022 · 8-4 | #23 | #42 |
| NC State2023 · 9-3 | #18 | #32 |
| Clemson2023 · 8-4 | #22 | #33 |
The committee gives less credit for how hard the schedule was.
Smaller conferences
No steady pattern
| Team | Committee | Yardstick |
|---|---|---|
| Army2024 · 11-2 | #22 | #37 |
| Memphis2024 · 10-2 | #25 | #40 |
In 2024 the committee was much kinder to two shiny records against soft schedules. In the other four seasons it ranked smaller-conference teams a little lower than the Yardstick did.
By conference
| Conference | Average gap |
|---|---|
| SEC | less than 1 spot apart |
| Big Ten | about 2 spots lower with the committee |
| Big 12 | about 1 spot lower with the committee |
| ACC | about 4 spots higher with the committee |
The one steady lean is toward the ACC. The committee ranked its teams higher in all five seasons.
Where the Yardstick saw it first
The Yardstick had both teams higher
| Team | Committee | Yardstick |
|---|---|---|
| Miami2025 · reached the title game | #10 | #7 |
| Ohio State2024 · won the title | #6 | #4 |
Two cases, not proof, but both point the same way.
Team-by-team comparisons are on the Past seasons tab.
The bottom line
The committee and the Yardstick ask the same questions: How many losses? How bad? Who did you beat? Who did you play? Did you play each other? The difference is that the committee answers them differently each year, and only for teams it calls comparable. The Yardstick writes the answers down once and applies them to every team, every week.
Based on the committee’s final rankings and the chairs’ public explanations, 2021 to 2025. Sources: CFP selection committee protocol and final rankings; chair interviews and transcripts reported by On3, CBS Sports, Sports Illustrated, ESPN and Irish Sports Daily.