A fair way to measure
The committee’s own logic, written down.
Give college football one objective way to rank teams for the playoff. The rules are built on what the playoff committee itself weighs. Then they are written down, so they are the same for every team and any fan can check them.
Every week, college football rankings start arguments. Polls and the playoff committee rely on judgment, and judgment changes from week to week and team to team. A loss counts heavily for one team and gets explained away for another.
The Yardstick is a proposal for a better way: a ranking that is
- Objective. Built only from what happened on the field. No preseason hype, no brand names, no polls.
- Consistent. The same rules for every team, every week. The method is written down, and it does not change to fit a result.
- Fair. Record matters, and so does who you played. Losing at #3 is not the same as losing at #90, and a soft schedule cannot hide.
- Open. Every rank can be traced step by step. Close calls are labeled, not hidden.
Think of the strike zone on a TV broadcast. You can argue about where the box should be drawn. But once it is drawn, every pitch is judged against the same box, and everyone can see where the ball landed. The Yardstick tries to do that for college football. The rules are on the How it works tab.
Built on the committee’s own logic
The Yardstick does not invent new things to care about. It starts with what the playoff committee says it weighs, and with what its rankings have rewarded since 2021. Then it turns each one into a fixed rule.
| What the committee weighs | The Yardstick’s fixed rule |
|---|---|
| Who are the best teams? | Step 1 · Power rating →Y power. A rating built from yards per play and points, adjusted for who each team played. |
| Losses come first | Step 2 · The loss rule →A team cannot pass a team with two or more fewer losses, unless its schedule is much harder. |
| Strength of schedule | Steps 2 and 3 · Schedule rule and schedule adjustment →It counts every week, the same way. A much weaker schedule cannot pass a much tougher one. Step 3 then asks how the team did against that schedule. |
| Best wins and bad losses | Step 3 · Points for wins and losses →A points card. A win is worth more the better the opponent. A loss costs more the weaker the opponent. |
| Head-to-head | Step 4 · Head-to-head →Between close teams, the winner goes above the loser. |
The difference is how the factors are used. The committee weighs them by judgment, and the weight can change from year to year. The Yardstick applies them the same way every time.
It also leaves out the parts that rest on opinion. There is no eye test, no injury adjustment, no conference label and no credit for last week’s rank.
How the committee decided, year by year, and where the Yardstick does it differently, is under Vs. the committee.
What it is not
It is not a betting model. Earned is what teams have done so far. Projected is a look ahead at where the season is heading if the favorites win. It is not a promise. And none of it is the last word: it is one clear, consistent yardstick that anyone can check and argue with.
Who built it, and what is judgment
The Yardstick is an independent project built by one college football fan. He is a Notre Dame fan. Notre Dame is ranked by the same steps as every other team, and its page shows the math.
The rules themselves involve choices: how much a win is worth, how wide the schedule groups are, how far head-to-head reaches. Those choices are judgment. The difference is that they are written down and they are the same for every team. A rule is never bent for one team. When a rule changes, it changes for everyone, the version number goes up, and the reason is recorded.
Follow and contact
New rankings come out every week of the season. Follow along on X and Bluesky (@theyardstickt24) for each week’s ranking, how it lines up with the committee, and the games to watch.
Questions, corrections or feedback are welcome. Email hello@theyardsticksports.com.